Pictured is the Elm Street School, constructed 1908-1910. It is an example of a local historic asset which has been saved from demolition. This building replaced an even earlier wooden schoolhouse which stood on the same property from 1888 until 1910. The construction of the brick Elm Street School was the largest and most expensive project the township had undertaken to date. It was a civic anchor in the growing Village of Stirling. The building served as a public school and later as administrative office space for the Board of Education until 1996. The Board of Education's plan to demolish the building and sell the property was reevaluated at the urging of the Committee members. Instead, in late 2002 the building was sold to a private developer who will reconfigure the interior space of the building to meet modern office needs while preserving and restoring the exterior look of the local landmark as it approaches the beginning of its second century.
The Historic Preservation Advisory Committee was active in preventing the destruction of the Torrey homestead, once called "Hilltop", on Long Hill Road in Stirling. From the late 1870s until the mid 1920s, the edifice was home to the family of one of Stirling's founders, Herbert G. Torrey, who was also known nationally because of his expertise as a scientist, metallurgist, mineralogist, and who served as Chief Assayer of the US Mint. Torrey's father was the internationally renowned botanist John Torrey MD, LLD, the founder of the
Torrey Botanical Society in New York and a founding member of the National Academy of Sciences. Dr. Torrey is buried in the family plot in Stirling. The home remains a mecca for latter day fans of these two pioneering generations of American science.
Since 1924 the building had been home to the Blessed Trinity Missionary Retreat Cenacle.
A contractor had been planning a small development of new homes on the 27 acre Torrey estate. His original plan called for the demolition of the historic home and its replacement with a new house. With cooperation from the Planning Board and the developer, an alternative plan was formulated in which the developer agreed to separate the historic building from the rest of his development.
The old homestead with historic preservation deed easements and several acres of surrounding land were put on the market in hopes of attracting a buyer interested in restoring the house to its Victorian grandeur. At the eleventh hour, after several extensions from the developer and in spite of the 9/11 disruptions, a buyer came forward and bought the house. It is now undergoing a long-term restoration as a private home. The historic easements permit updating the interior, but will preserve the exterior streetscape as it appears from Long Hill Road.
- For more about the Torrey family and the house (with more photos), visit Larry Fast's Torrey Mansion webpage.
- Also see the June page of the 2003 Township calendar for additional photos.
- Read more about the relationship between the Torrey family and Stirling on the NY-NJ-CT Botany website.
UPDATING THE ACROTERION REPORT
The Advisory Committee's first order of business is to inventory our historic assets. Some public buildings are well-known. Many historic township homes were documented in a 1986 Morris County funded survey of the Township known as the Acroterion Report. A copy of this report may be viewed at the Township Library.
The survey's authors attempted to include individual reports on all of the older buildings in town. Acroterion tried to report on all of the buildings built prior to 1900, although they also included some buildings that were built as late as the outbreak of World War II. But there are errors and omissions in the report. The Historic Preservation Advisory Committee in association with the Long Hill Township Historical Society is going to correct and update this comprehensive report.
If you note that your historic house is not included, please inform the Advisory Committee. If you have more information about your site, we'd like to include that in the revised report. If you have an historic period photo or a more recent photo that we could borrow and scan, we can include that in our update.
A preliminary version of this report in web-viewable electronic form has been shared with the Morris County Planning office. When the updated information has stabilized, the Historic Preservation Advisory Committee will make the entire report available on Long Hill Township website.